NOTES ON THE TEXT
by Clifton Coles
The libretto of The Beauty Stone used here is an early one,
possibly corresponding to the text used on opening night. Other
editions are decidedly shorter, the major excisions being verses
for Barbe and Isabeau in the beauty pageant scene and two songs:
a trio ("'Tis she! 'tis she! our little Laine" in Act II, scene
2) and a duet ("Up and down" in Act II, scene 3). These numbers
were performed on opening night. The review in the Times mentions
two duets for the Devil and Jacqueline as opposed to the one
published, as well as solos for all three principal beauty
contestants instead of for only one (Loyse) as at present. The
vocal score corresponds with the later edition of the libretto,
the same musical sections being omitted.
There are many instances where lyrics differ between the
vocal score and the libretto. Some of these discrepancies are
completely arbitrary and may derive from the composer working
from an earlier text or from changes made after the printing of
the source libretto. In most instances where rhyme or reason is
unaffected, the vocal score's words have been chosen.
The Beauty Stone was one of the earliest Sullivan (non-
Gilbert) opera blessed with a recording. A Pavilion Records set
by the Prince Consort and chorus of the Gilbert and Sullivan
Society of Edinburgh was released in 1984. The recording is more
or less complete, omitting as it does all material inconsistent
with the opera's second version (that is, the two songs and the
beauty pageant verses mentioned above).
The recording also includes a march corresponding with
Philip's first entrance in Act I, scene 2, following the repeat
of the chorus "The bells are ringing o'er Mirlemont town." The
march is not included in the vocal score or the piano score, nor
does the chorus itself appear at this point in either. The
libretto, however, supports "background music" at this point, and
the chorus may have made up the first portion of the march, as
the music on the recording corresponds to these words.
The Library of Congress has a piano score that does not
include any lyrics. It has no march at this point either.